When a doctor or nurse asks you who is
your emergency contact, do you know whom they are asking about – 1) the
actual person to contact for an emergency, 2) the person who is
authorized to speak for you near the end-of-life, or 3) the person
authorized to make decisions for you and has a durable medical power
of attorney.
WARNING! Most medical providers
and hospitals use the first one mistakenly. There is a difference in
how these people may do things for you. The first person generally
is the person that will contact the rest of the family and can make
some minor decisions. Often this person is a spouse and often can
fill all three roles.
Sometimes the spouse does not want the
responsibility or is incapable of acting and the person in role 2
above is correct. This person can be a trusted friend, family member
(an adult son or daughter), or other relative. The third role is the
most difficult and most doctors and hospitals do not want to see this
one and will often do their best to side step this person. Sometimes
this person can also be an advocate for the patient and the medical
profession will totally ignore this person serving in dual roles.
The point I am trying to make, don't
count on your wishes being followed. I have seen this violated more
often than I care to remember. It is violated by everyone from
nurses to doctors, to hospital employees, to hospital administrators,
and family members and this makes me sick.
Then to read about this study at the
Henry Ford Hospital in Detroit added to my concerns. More than 95
percent of patients treated in an Emergency Department mistake their
emergency contact as the designated medical decision maker for
end-of-life care, according to a new study by Henry Ford Hospital in
Detroit. The study is being presented Wednesday at the 20th
International Congress on Palliative Care in Montreal.
The researchers sought to determine
whether there was a correlation between the role of an emergency
contact and advance directive. At various entry points into the
health care system, patients are repeatedly asked to provide
emergency contact information even though the health care industry
doesn’t universally define what that is.
“For its study, researchers
surveyed 308 patients who were treated in Henry Ford’s Emergency
Department in Detroit between December 2012 and April 2013. Of that
number, 34 patients had an advance directive but only half of them
provided a copy of it to their primary care physician.
Highlights of the survey:
• 99 percent said their emergency
contact should be able to come to the hospital if needed.
• 97 percent of patients said they wanted their emergency contact to notify important family members if they were sick and could not do so.
• 97 percent of patients said their emergency contact should know what type of care they would want if they could not voice it.
• 95 percent expected their emergency contact should be able to tell the medical team what their wishes were if they could not.
• 97 percent of patients said they wanted their emergency contact to notify important family members if they were sick and could not do so.
• 97 percent of patients said their emergency contact should know what type of care they would want if they could not voice it.
• 95 percent expected their emergency contact should be able to tell the medical team what their wishes were if they could not.
When asked why they chose their
emergency contact:
• 80 percent of patients said the emergency contact was the best way to get in touch with them.
• 43 percent said they were the designated medical decision maker.”
• 80 percent of patients said the emergency contact was the best way to get in touch with them.
• 43 percent said they were the designated medical decision maker.”
“Erin Zimny, M.D., a Henry Ford
Emergency Medicine and Palliative Care physician and a study
co-author, says health literacy, which is one reason cited for low
advance directive completion rates, did not play a role in their
study.
“We’re using an antiquated
vocabulary in medicine,” she says. “We should be asking and
educating patients about the importance of an advance directive
instead of defaulting to the emergency contact world.” “
The study was funded by Henry Ford
Hospital.
This type of information puts everyone
on notice that more care needs to be taken to make sure that your
wishes are followed. More on this in a future blog.