Showing posts with label Noncompliance according to doctors. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Noncompliance according to doctors. Show all posts

June 1, 2014

A Discussion about 'Noncompliant Patients'

While most doctors still label patients as non-compliant, a few doctors are speaking out against this and this doctor-to-be says even doctors are often the most non-compliant. It is called guideline non-adherence. I thought this was most appropriate and fit the discussion to a tee.

Elaine Khoong says, “What bothers me the most about this phrase, though, is how it’s often stated with such disdain. We act as if it’s incomprehensible that someone would ignore our evidence-based recommendations. If the patient would only bother to listen, he or she would get better. If we were patients, we would be compliant.

But that’s simply not true. We are no different from our patients. We practice our own form of noncompliance. Despite the fact that many guidelines are created after systematic reviews and meta-analyses – processes we would never have time to go through ourselves – we, like our own patients, are often noncompliant.”

I think she states this correctly and to the point. She does continue with more evidence about how doctors ignore guidelines and practice as they see fit. They ignore what they want to in the guidelines and use the parts they are comfortable in using. When they have not kept up with a treatment, they fall back to what is easy for them.

We see this with diabetes all the time and doctors just don't keep abreast with the treatments they are not comfortable in using. This is especially true when it comes to insulin. Why else would they stack oral medications on top of other oral medications? It is plain that they don't know enough about insulin to prescribe it.

The doctors then intimidate patients and belittle patients to stay on oral medications. Some even threaten their patients with insulin to keep them on oral medications. Then when the patients know that the oral medications are no longer helping them manage their diabetes, the doctors say they are non-compliant and say bad things to and about patients. It is clear that the doctors are non-adherent in staying current with the diabetes treatments and they will not admit it.

Fortunately, today there are more doctors and doctors-to-be that do not believe patients are non-compliant without a reason. Doctors that refuse to communicate and talk with their patients are the worst offenders. These doctors talk at or don't communicate with their patients.

The patients of today do desire more inclusion in their treatments and change doctors that exclude them in the decisions. Yet, these same doctors blame the patients for not following instructions when they don't follow the treatment guidelines.

January 30, 2014

My Perspective On Reasons Doctors Say We Are Noncompliant

This Medscape article has me riled. Doctors are complaining about a noncompliance epidemic and how to solve it. There are seven articles of several pages each and all are attempting to solve the epidemic.

I have an easy answer for them and I don't need over 30 pages to tell doctors the problem. Learn how to communicate with patients rather than ram medications down our throat. Most of the time these doctors just hand the patient a fist full of prescriptions with no explanation and expect the patient to fill each prescription and take the medication as directed. A small number of patients will comply with no questions asked. However, more patients are pushing back, want an explanation of what the medication is for, an explanation of the side effects, a benefits to harm analysis, and want a discussion of why they need it. Then even more patients desire to have some input in the decision of what may be best for them and openly rebel at being excluded by the paternalistic attitude of the doctor. Today's patient also wants more transparency on the part of the doctor and if he receives incentives for each prescription.

Most doctors refuse to take the time for any explanation and are upset with the patients when prescriptions are not filled and the patients refuse to take any medications. Their own lack of communication causes the majority of noncompliance as they deem to call it. These paternalistic doctors need a swift kick in the backside and be required to take and pass a communications course. It is the lack of communication not the miscommunication as they try to say in #7 below,

Doctors do not seem to care whether the patient can afford the medication as long as their bill is paid. They seem to forget that a little communication can do wonders for their practice and the confidence their patients have in them. I therefore say that the patient rebellion is mostly of their own causing. Yet, it is full speed ahead at blaming the patient, instead of looking at what they are doing.

David Mendosa is a bit more forceful in his blog from October 30, 2009. This was when more people were afraid to walk away from these doctors; however, today the doctors are forcing us to walk away more because of the over paternalistic attitude. With more people using the internet, we are able to understand the problems of pharmaceutical overreach and lack of communication about side effects that cause more harm than benefits for some people. I like a quote David used at the bottom of his blog by an endocrinologist friend, “The ‘noncompliant’ label always grated on me — it’s assuming a model of health care delivery that the doctor is the captain of the ship and the patients are chained to the oars.”

The following links will take you to each article: NOTE: These are written by doctors and for doctors – sort of an insight in the way we, as patients, are viewed.

Title - Why Are So Many Patients Noncompliant? - 9 pages

Title - Can We Get Patients to Be More Compliant? - 9 pages

Title - Documenting Noncompliance Won't Protect You Anymore – 4 pages

Title - Best Ways to Deal With Noncompliant Patients – 6 pages

Title - Noncompliance With Schizophrenia Therapy Usually Persists – 1 page

Title - Patients: 'Difficult,' 'Tough,' or Just Misunderstood? - 3 pages

Title - Why Some Patients Aren't Following Your Instructions – 4 pages

This is the master collection of the above articles